They also have a cool thing that's not online but at Target where you can custom make your own four color eye shadow pallet. Which is perfect for me who always loves two out of the four shades in manufactured pallets.
They have other things that are more "expensive."
I also got this blush for $3 and I love the color on my skin.
It's definitely coming with me to Europe.
I typically am skeptical with cheap make-up but in my head I thought "well, it's only $1."
I am happy thus far with my purchases and I am especially in love with the Glossy Gloss
(that one is not on the website but at Target).
I applied it right before going out with a friend and it stayed on through
Dark Chocolate Fudge Cold Stone Ice Cream and one hour of dress shopping.
Have you tried E.L.F.?
What were the results?
What make-up things do you refuse to be cheap about?
ps... I danced with this girl who always had the most amazing eye make-up.
I asked her if she used MAC.
She said: "No.Wet 'n' Wild."
There you go.